Summary of We Were Liars
This We Were Liars book review explores E. Lockhart’s bestselling YA novel about the wealthy Sinclair family. The story follows Cadence Sinclair Eastman as she uncovers dark truths about a mysterious accident during her 15th summer on the family’s private island. Through poetic prose and shocking revelations, We Were Liars examines themes of privilege, trauma, and the destructive power of secrets.
In this We Were Liars book review, we analyze the novel’s unconventional narrative structure. The story unfolds through Cadence’s fragmented memories and fairy-tale allegories, building to a devastating twist. Readers gradually learn that Cadence’s “accident” was actually a suicide attempt following a tragic fire she accidentally caused – a truth her mind had suppressed.
Why Is It Called “We Were Liars”? Unpacking the Title’s Hidden Meanings
The title We Were Liars operates on multiple narrative and thematic levels. At its most literal, it refers to the childhood nickname given to Cadence, Gat, Johnny, and Mirren by the Sinclair family after they earned a reputation for mischievous lies—like denying they tracked mud indoors as kids :cite[3]:cite[8]. However, the deluxe edition reveals this origin story was cut from the final draft, leaving the title intentionally ambiguous :cite[1]. Metaphorically, it critiques the Sinclair family’s culture of deception: the adults manipulate inheritance plans while pressuring the teens to lie about their happiness to maintain appearances :cite[9]. The past tense (“Were“) foreshadows the tragic twist—the Liars (except Cadence) died in the fire, making their existence a literal lie throughout most of the narrative :cite[4].
Beyond plot, the title reflects the novel’s exploration of subjective truth. Cadence’s unreliable narration—like her metaphorical claim that her father “shot [her] in the chest” when he left—blurs reality and invention :cite[7]. The Liars’ ghostly presence in Summer 17 further destabilizes truth, as Cadence unconsciously fabricates interactions with her dead friends :cite[6]. Even the Sinclair family’s “perfect” WASP identity is revealed as a lie masking dysfunction :cite[9]. As one reader noted, the title ironically highlights that the Liars were the only ones not lying—they saw through the family’s facades :cite[8], making their nickname a twisted badge of honesty in a world built on deception.
Who Is We Were Liars Suitable For?
This We Were Liars book review suggests the novel is ideal for young adults who enjoy psychological thrillers. The book’s exploration of mental health and family dysfunction makes it particularly relevant for readers aged 13+. Fans of unreliable narrators and atmospheric mysteries will appreciate Lockhart’s unique storytelling approach.
As noted in this We Were Liars book review, the novel does contain mature themes including death, addiction, and self-harm. While some critics find the protagonist’s privileged perspective limiting, others praise the raw emotional honesty. The book’s ambiguous ending makes it excellent for book club discussions.
About the Author (E. Lockhart)
In our We Were Liars book review, we highlight E. Lockhart’s impressive credentials. The pen name of Emily Jenkins, Lockhart is a National Book Award finalist known for her sharp examinations of class and identity. Her background in Shakespearean literature influenced We Were Liars, which echoes themes from King Lear.
This We Were Liars book review also mentions Lockhart’s other notable works, including Genuine Fraud and The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks. With the upcoming Prime Video adaptation and a new companion novel, We Fell Apart, releasing in November 2025, Lockhart’s literary influence continues to grow.
Quotations from the Book
Our We Were Liars book review features several memorable quotes that showcase Lockhart’s distinctive voice. The ironic refrain “Welcome to the beautiful Sinclair family. No one is a criminal. No one is an addict. No one is a failure” perfectly captures the family’s toxic perfectionism.
This We Were Liars book review also highlights the novel’s striking metaphorical language. Passages like “Then he pulled out a handgun and shot me in the chest… Blood gushed rhythmically from my open wound” powerfully convey emotional pain through physical imagery.
Readers’ and Experts’ Opinions
This We Were Liars book review synthesizes diverse critical perspectives. While NPR praised the twist as “mind-blowing,” some readers found the protagonist’s privilege alienating. The Guardian called it “phenomenal” for its emotional depth, though Common Sense Media noted character relatability issues.
Our We Were Liars book review acknowledges the divided opinions on Lockhart’s narrative style. Some critics view the fragmented prose as innovative, while others find it gimmicky. Regardless, the novel’s cultural impact is undeniable, with over 1.2 million Goodreads ratings.
Where to Buy or Download PDF of We Were Liars
This We Were Liars book review provides purchasing information for interested readers. The novel is available in print ($17.99) and digital formats across major retailers like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Bookshop.org. The audiobook, narrated by Ariadne Meyers, comes highly recommended.
Our We Were Liars book review notes that international readers can find translations on platforms like Audible and Kobo. With the Prime Video adaptation in development, new special editions with bonus content are expected to release soon.