Introduction
Holly Jackson, the bestselling author of *A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder*, returns with her latest thriller, *The Reappearance of Rachel Price*. This highly anticipated 2024 release has already garnered attention for its gripping plot, complex characters, and signature Jackson twists. In this review, we’ll dive into the story, its strengths, and a few areas where it might not hit the mark for every reader.
Plot Overview
*The Reappearance of Rachel Price* follows 18-year-old Belle, whose mother, Rachel, mysteriously disappeared 16 years ago. Belle was only two when her mother vanished, leaving behind a trail of unanswered questions and theories—ranging from foul play to abandonment. The story kicks off with a documentary crew arriving in Belle’s small Michigan town to investigate Rachel’s disappearance, reopening old wounds and stirring up family secrets.
About 20% into the book, Rachel suddenly reappears, claiming no memory of what happened. Her return throws Belle’s life into chaos as she struggles to reconcile the stranger in her home with the mother she never knew. Belle, skeptical of Rachel’s story, teams up with Ash, a young man from the documentary crew, to uncover the truth.
Strengths of the Book
1. Compelling Characters
Belle is a standout protagonist—sassy, sarcastic, and fiercely intelligent. Her dry humor and resilience make her a joy to follow, and her emotional journey as she grapples with her mother’s reappearance is both relatable and heart-wrenching. The supporting cast, including Belle’s father, cousin, and the enigmatic Ash, are equally well-developed, adding depth to the family dynamics and the story’s tension.
2. Documentary Element
The documentary framing device is a brilliant addition, giving the story a modern, true-crime feel. Jackson’s attention to detail, from reenactments to interviews, makes the narrative feel authentic and immersive. Fans of podcasts and true crime will appreciate this layer of storytelling.
3. Atmospheric and Cinematic
The book’s pacing, while slow at times, builds suspense effectively. Jackson takes her time exploring the characters and their relationships, creating a sense of unease that keeps readers hooked. The final act is particularly cinematic, with twists and turns that feel like watching a thriller unfold on screen.
Areas of Critique
1. Pacing
At over 16 hours of audiobook (likely around 500 pages), *The Reappearance of Rachel Price* is a long read. While the slow burn works for character development, some readers may find the pacing too leisurely, especially in the first half.
2. Too Many Twists
The book’s biggest flaw lies in its overabundance of twists. While the initial revelations are gripping, the final act piles on too many, making the resolution feel convoluted. A simpler, more focused ending would have been more satisfying.
3. Minor Plot Holes
There are a few minor inconsistencies in the story’s resolution that require readers to suspend disbelief. While not deal-breakers, they may bother those who prefer airtight plots.
Audiobook Experience
The audiobook, narrated with skill and nuance, is an excellent way to experience this story. At 16 hours, it’s a commitment, but the engaging narration and immersive storytelling make it worth the time.
Final Thoughts
*The Reappearance of Rachel Price* is another strong entry in Holly Jackson’s bibliography, showcasing her talent for crafting suspenseful, character-driven thrillers. While the pacing and excessive twists may not work for everyone, the book’s emotional depth, humor, and cinematic quality make it a must-read for fans of Jackson and the YA thriller genre.
Rating: 4.5/5 stars
Should You Read It?
If you’re a fan of Holly Jackson’s previous works or enjoy slow-burn thrillers with complex characters and true-crime elements, this book is for you. However, if you prefer fast-paced plots or dislike multiple twists, you might want to approach with caution.
Let us know in the comments—are you planning to read *The Reappearance of Rachel Price*? What’s your favorite Holly Jackson book?